//! Proof of possession of a room grant's key (WAI live-rooms §10.5.2), over each transport, //! with the relay reading the client's SETUP before it sends its own //! (`draft-ietf-moq-privacy-pass-auth-04` §3.5.1): //! //! - the relay sends nothing before the client's SETUP; //! - at -22 over each transport, and at -23, -18 and -16 through the bridge, the same: //! a client that holds no challenge presents its grant unproved and is refused `pop_missing`, //! the relay's SETUP carrying `GRANT_REFUSED` and a challenge; its second session proves over //! that challenge and has the grant's rights; the SETUP that admits it carries the next //! challenge, which a third session proves over at once; //! - planted, each refused with its reason and nothing served: the grant as a bare token, a //! proof by another key, one for another relay, one over a challenge already consumed //! (`pop_replayed`), one over a challenge the relay never issued, and one over a challenge //! past its time; //! - a client that does not know `GRANT_REFUSED` stays, and the relay closes its session //! UNAUTHORIZED (§12.2) with the reason; //! - a grant presented later in a request, never proved, is refused that request. mod common; use common::*; use ed25519_dalek::SigningKey; use joule_moq::draft22::{Parameter, Parameters, RequestErrorCode, SessionError, Token}; use joule_moq::grant_proof; use joule_moq_relay::client::{Client, ClientOptions}; use joule_moq_relay::config::Grant; use joule_moq_relay::transport::TransportError; use joule_moq_relay::RelayServer; use std::time::Duration; use tokio::time::timeout; /// A record shaped as a room grant (`WRG1`, version 1, a room, the principal), which is /// all the relay reads of it: its rule names the record by its SHA-256. fn grant_record(room: u8, principal: &SigningKey) -> Vec { let mut g = b"WRG1\x01".to_vec(); g.extend_from_slice(&[room; 32]); g.extend_from_slice(&principal.verifying_key().to_bytes()); g.extend_from_slice(&[0x5a; 160]); g.extend_from_slice(&[0x77; 64]); g } /// The `//authority/path` a test client addresses over `via`: the URL's over WebTransport /// and the WebSocket binding; over native QUIC, with no AUTHORITY or PATH sent, `//`. fn target_of(server: &RelayServer, via: Via) -> String { let path = server.relay().config().path.clone(); match via { Via::Quic | Via::QuicDraft(_) => "//".into(), Via::WebTransport | Via::WtDraft(_) => format!("//127.0.0.1:{}{path}", server.quic_addr.unwrap().port()), Via::WebSocket | Via::WsDraft(_) => format!("//{}{path}", server.websocket_addr.unwrap()), #[cfg(feature = "webtransport-h2")] Via::WtH2 | Via::WtH2Draft(_) => format!("//127.0.0.1:{}{path}", server.webtransport_h2_addr.unwrap().port()), } } async fn closed_unauthorized(c: &Client, what: &str) { match timeout(STEP, c.conn.closed()).await.expect("closed in time") { TransportError::Closed { code, .. } => assert_eq!(code, SessionError::UNAUTHORIZED.0, "{what}"), other => panic!("{what}: {other:?}"), } } #[tokio::test(flavor = "multi_thread", worker_threads = 4)] async fn a_grant_is_honoured_only_with_its_proof() { timeout(Duration::from_secs(180), run()).await.expect("the test finishes in time"); } async fn run() { let host = SigningKey::from_bytes(&[0x41; 32]); let stranger = SigningKey::from_bytes(&[0x42; 32]); let record = grant_record(9, &host); let hash = hex::encode(joule_moq_relay::auth::sha256(&record)); let rule = |hash: String| Grant { prefix: vec!["room".into()], token_sha256: hash, publish: true, subscribe: true, proof: true, unlimited: false, seek: false }; let server = relay(|c| { c.auth.required = true; c.auth.grants = vec![rule(hash.clone())]; }) .await; let t = Tracks::new(ns(&["room", "host"]), "0", 10, 5, 128); let with = |key: &SigningKey, target: String| ClientOptions { grants: vec![(record.clone(), key.clone())], target, ..ClientOptions::default() }; let ws = target_of(&server, Via::WebSocket); // The relay's SETUP never comes before the client's: a session that sends nothing is sent // nothing. let (silent, _ep) = dial(&server, Via::Quic, None).await; assert!(timeout(Duration::from_millis(400), silent.accept_uni()).await.is_err(), "the relay sent its SETUP before it read the client's"); silent.close(0, b"done"); // A client that holds no challenge is refused and given one; its second session proves over // it; the SETUP that admits it gives the next, and a third session proves over that at once. // Over each transport at -22, and at each other draft the relay speaks, through its bridge: // the order, the options and the second session are the same at every one. use joule_moq::draft::Draft; let vias = [Via::WebSocket, Via::WebTransport, Via::Quic, Via::QuicDraft(Draft::D23), Via::WsDraft(Draft::D23), Via::QuicDraft(Draft::D18), Via::QuicDraft(Draft::D16)]; let mut challenges = Vec::new(); for via in vias { let opts = with(&host, target_of(&server, via)); let first = refused_at_setup(&server, via, opts.clone()).await; assert_eq!(first.reason, "pop_missing", "a grant presented with no proof"); let given = first.challenge.expect("the refusing SETUP carries a challenge"); let (conn, _ep) = dial(&server, via, None).await; let c = Client::connect(conn, ClientOptions { challenge: Some(given), ..opts.clone() }).await.expect("admitted on its second session"); let _held = publish_tracks(&c, &t, None).await; let next = c.challenge().expect("the admitting SETUP carries the next challenge"); c.close(0, "done"); let (conn, _ep) = dial(&server, via, None).await; let c = Client::connect(conn, ClientOptions { challenge: Some(next), ..opts }).await.expect("admitted at once, over the challenge its last SETUP gave"); let _held = publish_tracks(&c, &t, None).await; challenges.extend([given, next, c.challenge().expect("and gives another")]); c.close(0, "done"); } let consumed = challenges[0]; challenges.sort(); challenges.dedup(); assert_eq!(challenges.len(), 3 * vias.len(), "a relay never issues one challenge twice"); // Planted, each refused with its reason. let mut caught = 0; let fresh = || async { challenge_from(&server, Via::WebSocket, &with(&host, ws.clone())).await.expect("a challenge") }; let bare = ClientOptions { tokens: vec![Token::UseValue { token_type: 0, value: record.clone() }], ..ClientOptions::default() }; assert_eq!(refused_at_setup(&server, Via::WebSocket, bare.clone()).await.reason, "pop_missing", "the grant as a bare token"); caught += 1; let r = refused_at_setup(&server, Via::WebSocket, ClientOptions { challenge: Some(fresh().await), ..with(&stranger, ws.clone()) }).await; assert_eq!(r.reason, "pop_wrong_key", "a proof by another key"); caught += 1; let r = refused_at_setup(&server, Via::WebSocket, ClientOptions { challenge: Some(fresh().await), ..with(&host, "//other-relay.example/moq".into()) }).await; assert_eq!(r.reason, "pop_wrong_context", "a proof for another relay"); caught += 1; let r = refused_at_setup(&server, Via::WebSocket, ClientOptions { challenge: Some(consumed), ..with(&host, ws.clone()) }).await; assert_eq!(r.reason, "pop_replayed", "a proof over a challenge an admitted SETUP consumed"); caught += 1; let r = refused_at_setup(&server, Via::WebSocket, ClientOptions { challenge: Some([0x5e; 32]), ..with(&host, ws.clone()) }).await; assert_eq!(r.reason, "pop_wrong_challenge", "a proof over a challenge the relay never issued"); assert!(r.challenge.is_some(), "and a challenge to prove over is given with every refusal"); caught += 1; // A challenge is good at the relay that issued it: another relay holds none of this one's. let brief = relay(|c| { c.auth.required = true; c.auth.grants = vec![rule(hash.clone())]; c.limits.grant_challenge_ms = 150; }) .await; let theirs = target_of(&brief, Via::WebSocket); let r = refused_at_setup(&brief, Via::WebSocket, ClientOptions { challenge: Some(fresh().await), ..with(&host, theirs.clone()) }).await; assert_eq!(r.reason, "pop_wrong_challenge", "a challenge of another relay's"); caught += 1; // And for the time it states: past it, it is no challenge. let late = challenge_from(&brief, Via::WebSocket, &with(&host, theirs.clone())).await.expect("a challenge"); tokio::time::sleep(Duration::from_millis(400)).await; let r = refused_at_setup(&brief, Via::WebSocket, ClientOptions { challenge: Some(late), ..with(&host, theirs.clone()) }).await; assert_eq!(r.reason, "pop_wrong_challenge", "a challenge past its time"); caught += 1; // Within its time it is good: the same relay, the same grant. let (conn, _ep) = dial(&brief, Via::WebSocket, None).await; Client::connect(conn, ClientOptions { challenge: r.challenge, ..with(&host, theirs) }).await.expect("a proof over the challenge the refusal gave").close(0, "done"); brief.shutdown().await; eprintln!("planted faults caught (grant proofs): {caught} of 7"); // A client that does not know GRANT_REFUSED stays: the relay closes its session itself, // UNAUTHORIZED, with the reason. Nothing of it was served meanwhile. let (conn, _ep) = dial(&server, Via::WebSocket, None).await; let c = Client::connect(conn, ClientOptions { ignore_refusal: true, ..bare }).await.expect("the SETUPs are exchanged"); assert_eq!(grant_proof::refusal_of(&c.peer_setup.options).as_deref(), Some("pop_missing"), "the relay's SETUP says it refuses"); closed_unauthorized(&c, "a grant with no proof").await; // A grant presented only in a request, never proved in SETUP: refused that request. let (c, _) = connect(&server, Via::WebSocket, ClientOptions::default()).await; let late = Parameters::new().with(Parameter::AuthorizationToken(Token::UseValue { token_type: 0, value: record.clone() })); let refused = c.subscribe(t.ns.clone(), t.media.clone(), late).await.expect_err("a grant not proved"); assert!(refused.contains(&RequestErrorCode::UNAUTHORIZED.to_string()), "{refused}"); c.close(0, "done"); server.shutdown().await; }