{ "protocol": "wai.quantum.landscape/1", "options": { "sizes": [ 8, 12, 16, 24, 32, 48, 64, 96, 128 ], "dense_max": 64, "instances": 5, "seeds": 20, "budgets": [ 1, 8 ] }, "families": [ { "name": "clusters", "about": "sparse signed clustering, about degree 4, one link in eight contradicting the rest, cost 1" }, { "name": "sparse-glass", "about": "random signs on a sparse graph, about degree 6, cost 1" }, { "name": "dense-glass", "about": "random signs on every pair, cost 0" }, { "name": "selection", "about": "a hidden group of a quarter of the variables, all linked by sign, cost 1, with a known answer" } ], "solvers": [ "emulator, sampling, default start", "emulator, sampling, hot start", "emulator, deterministic", "simulated annealing", "tabu search", "greedy descent" ], "rows": [ { "family": "clusters", "n": 8, "pairs": 16, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 12800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 12800 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 12800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 12800 }, { "hits": 60, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 12800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 64331 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 12801, "operations_for_99_in_100": 12801 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 12809, "operations_for_99_in_100": 12809 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 12812, "operations_for_99_in_100": 12812 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 8, "pairs": 16, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 102400 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 102400 }, { "hits": 60, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 514650 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102401, "operations_for_99_in_100": 102401 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102411, "operations_for_99_in_100": 102411 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102413, "operations_for_99_in_100": 102413 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 12, "pairs": 24, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 19200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 19200 }, { "hits": 97, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 19200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 25215 }, { "hits": 55, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 19200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 110730 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 19200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 19200 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 19212, "operations_for_99_in_100": 19212 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 19219, "operations_for_99_in_100": 19219 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 12, "pairs": 24, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 153600 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 153600 }, { "hits": 55, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 885845 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153601, "operations_for_99_in_100": 153601 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153613, "operations_for_99_in_100": 153613 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153620, "operations_for_99_in_100": 153620 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 16, "pairs": 32, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 25600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 25600 }, { "hits": 97, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 25600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 33620 }, { "hits": 4, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 25600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2887961 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 25602, "operations_for_99_in_100": 25602 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 25618, "operations_for_99_in_100": 25618 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 25625, "operations_for_99_in_100": 25625 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 16, "pairs": 32, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 204800 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 204800 }, { "hits": 4, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 23103693 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204801, "operations_for_99_in_100": 204801 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204818, "operations_for_99_in_100": 204818 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204829, "operations_for_99_in_100": 204829 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 24, "pairs": 48, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 38400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 38400 }, { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 38400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 62855 }, { "hits": 20, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 38400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 792487 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 38401, "operations_for_99_in_100": 38401 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 38423, "operations_for_99_in_100": 38423 }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 38434, "operations_for_99_in_100": 38434 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 24, "pairs": 48, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 307200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 307200 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 307200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 307200 }, { "hits": 20, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 307200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 6339902 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 307202, "operations_for_99_in_100": 307202 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 307224, "operations_for_99_in_100": 307224 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 307237, "operations_for_99_in_100": 307237 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 32, "pairs": 64, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 97, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 51200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 67241 }, { "hits": 73, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 51200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 180079 }, { "hits": 19, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 51200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1118942 }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 51201, "operations_for_99_in_100": 51201 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 51232, "operations_for_99_in_100": 51232 }, { "hits": 82, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 51245, "operations_for_99_in_100": 137622 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 32, "pairs": 64, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 409600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 409600 }, { "hits": 96, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 409600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 586005 }, { "hits": 19, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 409600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8951539 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 409601, "operations_for_99_in_100": 409601 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 409633, "operations_for_99_in_100": 409633 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 409650, "operations_for_99_in_100": 409650 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 48, "pairs": 96, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 96, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 76800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 109875 }, { "hits": 46, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 76800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 573977 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 76800, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 98, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 76801, "operations_for_99_in_100": 90409 }, { "hits": 90, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 76839, "operations_for_99_in_100": 153679 }, { "hits": 62, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 76871, "operations_for_99_in_100": 365865 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 48, "pairs": 96, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 614400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 614400 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 614400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 614400 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 614400, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 614401, "operations_for_99_in_100": 614401 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 614448, "operations_for_99_in_100": 614448 }, { "hits": 98, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 614472, "operations_for_99_in_100": 723347 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 64, "pairs": 128, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 167614 }, { "hits": 35, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1094679 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102400, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 97, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102401, "operations_for_99_in_100": 134484 }, { "hits": 60, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102462, "operations_for_99_in_100": 514966 }, { "hits": 22, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 102496, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1899749 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 64, "pairs": 128, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 819200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 819200 }, { "hits": 93, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 819200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1418648 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 819200, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 819201, "operations_for_99_in_100": 819201 }, { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 819266, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1341027 }, { "hits": 40, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 819302, "operations_for_99_in_100": 7386135 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 96, "pairs": 192, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 56, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 861596 }, { "hits": 4, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17327770 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153600, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 86, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153601, "operations_for_99_in_100": 359777 }, { "hits": 18, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153701, "operations_for_99_in_100": 3566727 }, { "hits": 3, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 153748, "operations_for_99_in_100": 23245467 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 96, "pairs": 192, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 98, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1228800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1446523 }, { "hits": 80, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1228800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 3516030 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1228800, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1228802, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1228802 }, { "hits": 68, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1228899, "operations_for_99_in_100": 4966754 }, { "hits": 8, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1228941, "operations_for_99_in_100": 67874513 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 128, "pairs": 256, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 46, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1530607 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204800, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204800, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 79, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204801, "operations_for_99_in_100": 604330 }, { "hits": 7, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204944, "operations_for_99_in_100": 13005283 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 204995, "operations_for_99_in_100": null } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 128, "pairs": 256, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 91, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1638400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 3133422 }, { "hits": 67, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1638400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 6805596 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1638400, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1638401, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2681840 }, { "hits": 26, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1638543, "operations_for_99_in_100": 25060253 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1638583, "operations_for_99_in_100": null } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 8, "pairs": 24, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17920 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17920 }, { "hits": 21, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 350092 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17922, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17922 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17929, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17929 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17937, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17937 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 8, "pairs": 24, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 143360 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 143360 }, { "hits": 21, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2800740 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143362, "operations_for_99_in_100": 143362 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143371, "operations_for_99_in_100": 143371 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143379, "operations_for_99_in_100": 143379 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 12, "pairs": 36, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 26880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 26880 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 26880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 26880 }, { "hits": 27, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 26880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 393335 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 26882, "operations_for_99_in_100": 26882 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 26894, "operations_for_99_in_100": 26894 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 26905, "operations_for_99_in_100": 26905 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 12, "pairs": 36, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215040, "operations_for_99_in_100": 215040 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215040, "operations_for_99_in_100": 215040 }, { "hits": 27, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215040, "operations_for_99_in_100": 3146685 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215042, "operations_for_99_in_100": 215042 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215053, "operations_for_99_in_100": 215053 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215066, "operations_for_99_in_100": 215066 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 16, "pairs": 48, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 35840, "operations_for_99_in_100": 35840 }, { "hits": 90, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 35840, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71680 }, { "hits": 27, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 35840, "operations_for_99_in_100": 524447 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 35842, "operations_for_99_in_100": 35842 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 35859, "operations_for_99_in_100": 35859 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 35872, "operations_for_99_in_100": 35872 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 16, "pairs": 48, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286720, "operations_for_99_in_100": 286720 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286720, "operations_for_99_in_100": 286720 }, { "hits": 27, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286720, "operations_for_99_in_100": 4195580 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286722, "operations_for_99_in_100": 286722 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286737, "operations_for_99_in_100": 286737 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286756, "operations_for_99_in_100": 286756 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 24, "pairs": 72, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 53760, "operations_for_99_in_100": 53760 }, { "hits": 68, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 53760, "operations_for_99_in_100": 217277 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 53760, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 53762, "operations_for_99_in_100": 53762 }, { "hits": 97, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 53788, "operations_for_99_in_100": 70640 }, { "hits": 90, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 53817, "operations_for_99_in_100": 107634 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 24, "pairs": 72, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 430080, "operations_for_99_in_100": 430080 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 430080, "operations_for_99_in_100": 430080 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 430080, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 430082, "operations_for_99_in_100": 430082 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 430107, "operations_for_99_in_100": 430107 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 430128, "operations_for_99_in_100": 430128 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 32, "pairs": 96, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71680 }, { "hits": 74, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 245048 }, { "hits": 3, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10837399 }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71682, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71682 }, { "hits": 98, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71716, "operations_for_99_in_100": 84423 }, { "hits": 96, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71754, "operations_for_99_in_100": 102657 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 32, "pairs": 96, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 573440, "operations_for_99_in_100": 573440 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 573440, "operations_for_99_in_100": 573440 }, { "hits": 3, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 573440, "operations_for_99_in_100": 86699195 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 573442, "operations_for_99_in_100": 573442 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 573473, "operations_for_99_in_100": 573473 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 573513, "operations_for_99_in_100": 573513 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 48, "pairs": 144, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 77, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 107520, "operations_for_99_in_100": 336909 }, { "hits": 28, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 107520, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1507280 }, { "hits": 2, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 107520, "operations_for_99_in_100": 24508987 }, { "hits": 82, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 107522, "operations_for_99_in_100": 288757 }, { "hits": 58, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 107576, "operations_for_99_in_100": 571075 }, { "hits": 38, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 107616, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1036727 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 48, "pairs": 144, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 85, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 860160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2087998 }, { "hits": 83, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 860160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2235485 }, { "hits": 2, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 860160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 196071898 }, { "hits": 87, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 860162, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1941551 }, { "hits": 79, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 860212, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2538320 }, { "hits": 91, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 860260, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1645239 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 64, "pairs": 192, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 68, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 579407 }, { "hits": 2, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 32678649 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143360, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 90, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143362, "operations_for_99_in_100": 286725 }, { "hits": 28, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143424, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2010616 }, { "hits": 12, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 143497, "operations_for_99_in_100": 5169468 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 64, "pairs": 192, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1146880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1877286 }, { "hits": 87, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1146880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2588728 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1146880, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1146882, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1146882 }, { "hits": 65, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1146952, "operations_for_99_in_100": 5031245 }, { "hits": 42, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1146994, "operations_for_99_in_100": 9696787 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 96, "pairs": 288, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 37, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215040, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2143332 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215040, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215040, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 76, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215042, "operations_for_99_in_100": 693922 }, { "hits": 4, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215144, "operations_for_99_in_100": 24270642 }, { "hits": 1, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 215220, "operations_for_99_in_100": 98616355 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 96, "pairs": 288, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 87, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1720320, "operations_for_99_in_100": 3883092 }, { "hits": 69, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1720320, "operations_for_99_in_100": 6764413 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1720320, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 93, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1720322, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2979166 }, { "hits": 9, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1720423, "operations_for_99_in_100": 84007918 }, { "hits": 7, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1720500, "operations_for_99_in_100": 109179042 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 128, "pairs": 384, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 36, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286720, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2958621 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286720, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286720, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 71, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286723, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1066673 }, { "hits": 5, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286852, "operations_for_99_in_100": 25753943 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 286931, "operations_for_99_in_100": null } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 128, "pairs": 384, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 70, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2293760, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8773582 }, { "hits": 45, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2293760, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17668955 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2293760, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 84, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2293762, "operations_for_99_in_100": 5764091 }, { "hits": 14, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2293875, "operations_for_99_in_100": 70040338 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2294008, "operations_for_99_in_100": null } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 8, "pairs": 28, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 20480, "operations_for_99_in_100": 20480 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 20480, "operations_for_99_in_100": 20480 }, { "hits": 88, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 20480, "operations_for_99_in_100": 44482 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 20482, "operations_for_99_in_100": 20482 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 20484, "operations_for_99_in_100": 20484 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 20506, "operations_for_99_in_100": 20506 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 8, "pairs": 28, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 163840, "operations_for_99_in_100": 163840 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 163840, "operations_for_99_in_100": 163840 }, { "hits": 88, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 163840, "operations_for_99_in_100": 355857 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 163842, "operations_for_99_in_100": 163842 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 163848, "operations_for_99_in_100": 163848 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 163862, "operations_for_99_in_100": 163862 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 12, "pairs": 66, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 46080, "operations_for_99_in_100": 46080 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 46080, "operations_for_99_in_100": 46080 }, { "hits": 78, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 46080, "operations_for_99_in_100": 140150 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 46083, "operations_for_99_in_100": 46083 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 46086, "operations_for_99_in_100": 46086 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 46126, "operations_for_99_in_100": 46126 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 12, "pairs": 66, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 368640, "operations_for_99_in_100": 368640 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 368640, "operations_for_99_in_100": 368640 }, { "hits": 78, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 368640, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1121206 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 368643, "operations_for_99_in_100": 368643 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 368660, "operations_for_99_in_100": 368660 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 368687, "operations_for_99_in_100": 368687 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 16, "pairs": 120, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81920 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81920 }, { "hits": 39, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 763217 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81927, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81927 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81947, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81947 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 82007, "operations_for_99_in_100": 82007 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 16, "pairs": 120, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 655360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 655360 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 655360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 655360 }, { "hits": 39, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 655360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 6105739 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 655367, "operations_for_99_in_100": 655367 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 655385, "operations_for_99_in_100": 655385 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 655447, "operations_for_99_in_100": 655447 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 24, "pairs": 276, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 184320, "operations_for_99_in_100": 184320 }, { "hits": 95, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 184320, "operations_for_99_in_100": 283344 }, { "hits": 25, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 184320, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2950566 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 184332, "operations_for_99_in_100": 184332 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 184359, "operations_for_99_in_100": 184359 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 184502, "operations_for_99_in_100": 184502 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 24, "pairs": 276, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1474560, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1474560 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1474560, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1474560 }, { "hits": 25, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1474560, "operations_for_99_in_100": 23604528 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1474569, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1474569 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1474593, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1474593 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1474770, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1474770 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 32, "pairs": 496, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 327680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 536367 }, { "hits": 53, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 327680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1998645 }, { "hits": 4, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 327680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 36965909 }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 327697, "operations_for_99_in_100": 327697 }, { "hits": 95, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 327736, "operations_for_99_in_100": 503811 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 328039, "operations_for_99_in_100": 328039 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 32, "pairs": 496, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 98, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2621440, "operations_for_99_in_100": 3085916 }, { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2621440, "operations_for_99_in_100": 4290940 }, { "hits": 4, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2621440, "operations_for_99_in_100": 295727278 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2621451, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2621451 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2621481, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2621481 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2621820, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2621820 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 48, "pairs": 1128, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 94, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 737280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1206826 }, { "hits": 22, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 737280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 13665303 }, { "hits": 3, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 737280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 111470394 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 737340, "operations_for_99_in_100": 737340 }, { "hits": 92, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 737321, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1344361 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 738037, "operations_for_99_in_100": 738037 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 48, "pairs": 1128, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 5898240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 5898240 }, { "hits": 96, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 5898240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8438473 }, { "hits": 3, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 5898240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 891763156 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 5898264, "operations_for_99_in_100": 5898264 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 5898330, "operations_for_99_in_100": 5898330 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 5899028, "operations_for_99_in_100": 5899028 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 64, "pairs": 2016, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 81, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1310720, "operations_for_99_in_100": 3634597 }, { "hits": 4, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1310720, "operations_for_99_in_100": 147863639 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1310720, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 97, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1310864, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1721561 }, { "hits": 54, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1310756, "operations_for_99_in_100": 7773386 }, { "hits": 91, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1312018, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2509220 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 64, "pairs": 2016, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "best known", "solvers": [ { "hits": 96, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10485760, "operations_for_99_in_100": 15001731 }, { "hits": 90, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10485760, "operations_for_99_in_100": 20971520 }, { "hits": 0, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10485760, "operations_for_99_in_100": null }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10485791, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10485791 }, { "hits": 87, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10485895, "operations_for_99_in_100": 23668679 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10487106, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10487106 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 8, "pairs": 10, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 8960, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8960 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 8960, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8960 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 8960, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8960 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 8960, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8960 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 8967, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8967 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 8969, "operations_for_99_in_100": 8969 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 8, "pairs": 10, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71680 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71680 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71680 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71680, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71680 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71686, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71686 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 71687, "operations_for_99_in_100": 71687 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 12, "pairs": 10, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10240 }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10250, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10250 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 10251, "operations_for_99_in_100": 10251 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 12, "pairs": 10, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81920 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81920 }, { "hits": 99, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81920 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81920, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81920 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81930, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81930 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 81932, "operations_for_99_in_100": 81932 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 16, "pairs": 10, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 11520, "operations_for_99_in_100": 11520 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 11520, "operations_for_99_in_100": 11520 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 11520, "operations_for_99_in_100": 11520 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 11520, "operations_for_99_in_100": 11520 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 11536, "operations_for_99_in_100": 11536 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 11535, "operations_for_99_in_100": 11535 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 16, "pairs": 10, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "exact", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 92160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 92160 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 92160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 92160 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 92160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 92160 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 92160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 92160 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 92175, "operations_for_99_in_100": 92175 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 92175, "operations_for_99_in_100": 92175 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 24, "pairs": 15, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17309, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17309 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 17305, "operations_for_99_in_100": 17305 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 24, "pairs": 15, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 138240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 138240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 138240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 138240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 138240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 138240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 138240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 138240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 138265, "operations_for_99_in_100": 138265 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 138264, "operations_for_99_in_100": 138264 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 32, "pairs": 28, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 28160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 28160 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 28160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 28160 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 28160, "operations_for_99_in_100": 28160 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 28161, "operations_for_99_in_100": 28161 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 28185, "operations_for_99_in_100": 28185 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 28195, "operations_for_99_in_100": 28195 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 32, "pairs": 28, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 225280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 225280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 225280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 225280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 225280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 225280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 225280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 225280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 225311, "operations_for_99_in_100": 225311 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 225314, "operations_for_99_in_100": 225314 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 48, "pairs": 66, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 57600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 57600 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 57600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 57600 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 57600, "operations_for_99_in_100": 57600 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 57601, "operations_for_99_in_100": 57601 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 57625, "operations_for_99_in_100": 57625 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 57671, "operations_for_99_in_100": 57671 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 48, "pairs": 66, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 460800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 460800 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 460800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 460800 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 460800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 460800 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 460800, "operations_for_99_in_100": 460800 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 460845, "operations_for_99_in_100": 460845 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 460871, "operations_for_99_in_100": 460871 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 64, "pairs": 120, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 97280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 97280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 97280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 97280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 97280, "operations_for_99_in_100": 97280 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 97283, "operations_for_99_in_100": 97283 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 97344, "operations_for_99_in_100": 97344 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 97388, "operations_for_99_in_100": 97388 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 64, "pairs": 120, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 778240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 778240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 778240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 778240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 778240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 778240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 778240, "operations_for_99_in_100": 778240 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 778294, "operations_for_99_in_100": 778294 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 778362, "operations_for_99_in_100": 778362 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 96, "pairs": 276, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 207360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 207360 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 207360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 207360 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 207360, "operations_for_99_in_100": 207360 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 207404, "operations_for_99_in_100": 207404 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 207475, "operations_for_99_in_100": 207475 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 207611, "operations_for_99_in_100": 207611 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 96, "pairs": 276, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1658880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1658880 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1658880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1658880 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1658880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1658880 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1658880, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1658880 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1658968, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1658968 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 1659129, "operations_for_99_in_100": 1659129 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 128, "pairs": 496, "sweeps_per_start": 40, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 358400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 358400 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 358400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 358400 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 358400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 358400 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 358400, "operations_for_99_in_100": 358400 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 358502, "operations_for_99_in_100": 358502 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 358865, "operations_for_99_in_100": 358865 } ] }, { "family": "selection", "n": 128, "pairs": 496, "sweeps_per_start": 320, "target": "planted", "solvers": [ { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2867200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2867200 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2867200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2867200 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2867200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2867200 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2867200, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2867200 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2867325, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2867325 }, { "hits": 100, "runs": 100, "operations_per_run": 2867566, "operations_for_99_in_100": 2867566 } ] } ], "tally_default_start": { "rows": 68, "emulator_more": 2, "tied": 45, "classical_more": 21 }, "tally_hot_start": { "rows": 68, "emulator_more": 0, "tied": 38, "classical_more": 30 }, "start_temperature": [ { "family": "clusters", "n": 32, "default": 2.0, "hot": 9.0, "target": -16, "runs": 40, "rows": [ { "temperature": 0.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -16.0 }, { "temperature": 1.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -16.0 }, { "temperature": 1.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -16.0 }, { "temperature": 2.0, "is_default": true, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -16.0 }, { "temperature": 3.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -16.0 }, { "temperature": 4.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -16.0 }, { "temperature": 6.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 37, "mean_energy": -15.925 }, { "temperature": 8.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 29, "mean_energy": -15.725 }, { "temperature": 9.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": true, "reached_target": 28, "mean_energy": -15.65 } ] }, { "family": "clusters", "n": 64, "default": 2.0, "hot": 8.0, "target": -26, "runs": 40, "rows": [ { "temperature": 0.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 33, "mean_energy": -25.8 }, { "temperature": 1.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -26.0 }, { "temperature": 1.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 35, "mean_energy": -25.875 }, { "temperature": 2.0, "is_default": true, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 28, "mean_energy": -25.675 }, { "temperature": 3.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 22, "mean_energy": -25.4 }, { "temperature": 4.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 12, "mean_energy": -25.15 }, { "temperature": 6.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 6, "mean_energy": -24.475 }, { "temperature": 8.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": true, "reached_target": 1, "mean_energy": -23.35 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 32, "default": 2.449489742783178, "hot": 13.0, "target": -19, "runs": 40, "rows": [ { "temperature": 0.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -19.0 }, { "temperature": 1.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 38, "mean_energy": -18.95 }, { "temperature": 1.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 36, "mean_energy": -18.9 }, { "temperature": 2.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 37, "mean_energy": -18.925 }, { "temperature": 2.449489742783178, "is_default": true, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 33, "mean_energy": -18.825 }, { "temperature": 3.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 37, "mean_energy": -18.925 }, { "temperature": 4.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 36, "mean_energy": -18.9 }, { "temperature": 6.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 26, "mean_energy": -18.625 }, { "temperature": 8.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 25, "mean_energy": -18.55 }, { "temperature": 13.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": true, "reached_target": 15, "mean_energy": -18.175 } ] }, { "family": "sparse-glass", "n": 64, "default": 2.449489742783178, "hot": 12.0, "target": -51, "runs": 40, "rows": [ { "temperature": 0.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 39, "mean_energy": -50.975 }, { "temperature": 1.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -51.0 }, { "temperature": 1.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -51.0 }, { "temperature": 2.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 39, "mean_energy": -50.975 }, { "temperature": 2.449489742783178, "is_default": true, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -51.0 }, { "temperature": 3.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -51.0 }, { "temperature": 4.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 34, "mean_energy": -50.85 }, { "temperature": 6.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 26, "mean_energy": -50.5 }, { "temperature": 8.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 15, "mean_energy": -50.1 }, { "temperature": 12.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": true, "reached_target": 4, "mean_energy": -49.1 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 32, "default": 5.5677643628300215, "hot": 31.0, "target": -128, "runs": 40, "rows": [ { "temperature": 0.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 38, "mean_energy": -127.9 }, { "temperature": 1.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 39, "mean_energy": -127.95 }, { "temperature": 1.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 38, "mean_energy": -127.9 }, { "temperature": 2.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 39, "mean_energy": -127.95 }, { "temperature": 3.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -128.0 }, { "temperature": 4.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -128.0 }, { "temperature": 5.5677643628300215, "is_default": true, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 39, "mean_energy": -127.95 }, { "temperature": 6.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 39, "mean_energy": -127.95 }, { "temperature": 8.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -128.0 }, { "temperature": 31.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": true, "reached_target": 23, "mean_energy": -127.075 } ] }, { "family": "dense-glass", "n": 64, "default": 7.937253933193772, "hot": 63.0, "target": -362, "runs": 40, "rows": [ { "temperature": 0.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 29, "mean_energy": -360.55 }, { "temperature": 1.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -362.0 }, { "temperature": 1.5, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -362.0 }, { "temperature": 2.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -362.0 }, { "temperature": 3.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -362.0 }, { "temperature": 4.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 39, "mean_energy": -361.95 }, { "temperature": 6.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -362.0 }, { "temperature": 7.937253933193772, "is_default": true, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 38, "mean_energy": -361.9 }, { "temperature": 8.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": false, "reached_target": 40, "mean_energy": -362.0 }, { "temperature": 63.0, "is_default": false, "is_hot": true, "reached_target": 0, "mean_energy": -352.85 } ] } ] }